Japanese and Chinese knife steels: tradition meets modernity

Japanese and Chinese knife steels: tradition meets modernity

Japan and China are both known for their centuries-old traditions in knife and steel production. While Japan excels with its exceptionally high-quality steels and precise forging, China has gained prominence in recent decades with its inexpensive but high-performance steels. Both countries offer a wide range of steel types that cover both traditional and modern needs.

Japanese knife steels

Japan is famous worldwide for its blacksmithing, which is based on techniques originally developed for the production of samurai swords. Japanese knife steels are characterized by their hardness, fine grain and excellent edge retention.

Popular Japanese Steels

VG10

  • Category: High-performance stainless steel
  • Characteristics:
    VG10 is a stainless steel that is characterized by high hardness (60-62 HRC), excellent cutting ability and corrosion resistance. Due to its high carbon content and the addition of cobalt, it becomes extremely sharp and stays that way for a long time.
  • Use: High-quality kitchen knives and EDC knives.
  • Comparison: VG10 is similar to Sandvik 14C28N, but with higher cutting edge retention, but slightly more brittle.

Aogami (Blue Steel)

  • Category: Carbon steel
  • Characteristics:
    Aogami steels, such as Aogami #1 and Aogami Super , are known for their extreme sharpness and fine grain. They contain a high carbon content and additions of chromium and tungsten, which improves edge retention. However, they are not rustproof and require maintenance.
  • Use: Traditional Japanese knives such as Deba, Yanagiba and Usuba.
  • Comparison: Compared to Hitachi Shirogami (White Steel), Aogami offers better wear resistance with minimal loss of sharpness.

Shirogami (White Steel)

  • Category: Pure Carbon Steel
  • Characteristics:
    Shirogami, such as Shirogami #1 and Shirogami #2 , has an extremely high degree of purity and allows for razor-sharp blades. However, it is susceptible to rust and must be well cared for.
  • Use: Traditional knives for precision cuts.
  • Comparison: Sharper than Aogami, but less wear-resistant.

ZDP-189

  • Category: Powder metallurgical stainless steel
  • Characteristics:
    With an extremely high carbon content (about 3%) and high chromium content, ZDP-189 offers one of the best edge retention properties on the market. The hardness can reach up to 65-67 HRC, making it ideal for high-end knives.
  • Use: Premium EDC and kitchen knives.
  • Comparison: Better than VG10 in terms of edge retention, but harder to sharpen.

Advantages of Japanese steels

  1. Excellent sharpness: Japanese knife steels are designed for precise and sharp cutting edges.
  2. Fine grain: Carbon steels such as Aogami and Shirogami in particular offer an exceptionally fine microstructure.
  3. Traditional blacksmithing: The workmanship makes Japanese knives unique.

Chinese knife steels

China has developed strongly in recent decades and offers both inexpensive everyday steels and innovative high-performance steels. The quality of Chinese steels varies depending on the manufacturer, but there are some types of steel that have become internationally established.

Popular Chinese Steels

8Cr13MoV

  • Category: Stainless steel
  • Characteristics:
    8Cr13MoV is a versatile, inexpensive steel that offers good corrosion resistance, easy sharpening, and acceptable edge retention. It is often found in budget pocket knives.
  • Use: EDC knives, cheap kitchen knives.
  • Hardness: Typically 56-58 HRC.
  • Comparison: Similar to 440C, but easier to grind and less brittle.

9Cr18MoV

  • Category: Stainless steel
  • Characteristics:
    9Cr18MoV is a higher quality version of 8Cr13MoV with better cutting edge retention and higher corrosion resistance. The chromium content of 18% makes it particularly resistant to rust.
  • Use: Premium kitchen knives, outdoor knives.
  • Hardness: Typically 58-60 HRC.
  • Comparison: Comparable to VG10, but often cheaper.

D2 (Chinese version)

  • Category: Tool steel
  • Characteristics:
    The D2 steel produced in China is inexpensive but still offers good edge retention and toughness. Compared to American D2, the quality is sometimes inconsistent, but high-quality brands offer competitive alternatives.
  • Use: Tactical and outdoor knives.
  • Comparison: Slightly less robust than the original D2 from Crucible, but more attractively priced.

14C28N (Sandvik license production)

  • Category: Stainless steel
  • Characteristics:
    Some Chinese manufacturers license 14C28N from Sandvik and offer knives that have similar performance to the Swedish original, but at a lower price.

Advantages of Chinese steels

  1. Cost-effectiveness: Chinese steels like 8Cr13MoV offer good performance at an affordable price.
  2. Diversity: From simple everyday steels to high-performance steels, Chinese products cover a wide spectrum.
  3. Innovations: Some manufacturers are experimenting with new alloys to create high-performance alternatives to well-known brand steels.

Japanese vs. Chinese Steels: A Comparison

feature Japanese steels Chinese steels
sharpness Excellent (e.g. Aogami) Good (e.g. 9Cr18MoV)
corrosion resistance Very high (e.g. VG10, ZDP-189) High (e.g. 8Cr13MoV, 9Cr18MoV)
Cost High to Premium budget to mid-range
workmanship Traditional, very precise Variable, depending on the manufacturer

Conclusion

  • Japanese steels: Perfect for demanding users who are looking for the highest level of sharpness and precision. The combination of traditional forging and modern alloys makes them unbeatable for high-quality knives.
  • Chinese steels: An affordable and versatile alternative, especially suitable for beginners or budget buyers. However, high-quality brands also offer competitive steels in higher price ranges.

Back to blog